Issue 12
Thanks for your patience over the last few weeks. I'm glad to be back in your inbox, and I'll keep the Tuesday rhythm going.
Opening Take
Last week, Polymarket confirmed it laid off employees and ended contractor agreements after an internal email circulated on X. According to Fox Business, more than half of those affected were contractors, and a person familiar with the matter said the cuts mainly hit marketing, customer experience and engineering. Polymarket called a reported 30% workforce cut inaccurate but did not share its own number.
This does not look like a company short on cash. Polymarket says its annualized revenue passed $1.8 billion in November, and CDC Gaming reports two sources describe the goal as professionalizing the company ahead of a possible IPO. The pressure is Kalshi, which Reuters reports has overtaken Polymarket in monthly trading volume. DefiLlama data cited by Bankless shows about $17.7 billion on Kalshi over 30 days, against about $5.9 billion on Polymarket.
Here's my take. Both platforms list the same games, so this is a race over distribution and regulatory standing, not product. Any league, team or athletic department that signs a partnership is choosing a side in a fight that isn't settled. Sports made up roughly 87% of Kalshi's trading over the year through February, per a Congressional Research Service report, so I'm not sure sports organizations realize how much leverage they have.
If you work for a league, team or athletic department, has a prediction market platform approached you yet, and what did they offer? Reply and tell me.
What I'm Watching
- The 24-team CFP may squeeze the Group of 6 out of Power 4 schedules. Starting in 2027, Power 4 football teams need at least 10 qualifying games, which can be conference games, nonconference Power 4 games or games against Notre Dame. As written, that doesn't appear to count Group of 6 opponents. Conference USA commissioner Judy MacLeod says some Conference USA teams have already been dropped from schedules. Mountain West commissioner Gloria Nevarez says access to those opponents is getting harder. That matters because only the top-ranked Group of 6 champion gets an automatic bid, so everyone else needs a strong nonconference résumé. If the incentives all point inward, does the Power 4 end up playing mostly itself? Read more
- A college analytics vendor is building the data layer for a new high school league. ShotTracker, a basketball analytics and video platform used by Division I college programs, was named official technology partner of ATLAS, an international high school and academy basketball league from World Stage Sports. The league's inaugural season has 11 programs across six countries. According to the press release, ShotTracker will supply official stats, advanced analytics and game film across all league competitions, and the standardized data is meant for scouts, recruiters and media evaluating international prospects. No start date was given. Financial terms were not disclosed. If one vendor serves both the high school league and the college programs recruiting from it, what changes about how prospects get evaluated? Read more
- The Protect College Sports Act is racing the calendar, and the midterms changed the math. The Senate passed it 77-22 in September, and President Donald Trump has endorsed it. But Democrats won at least 247 House seats, and most House Democrats oppose the bill. The Republican-led House has only the lame-duck session to act, because a new Congress in January would mean starting over. Venable, a law firm, calls suspension of the rules, which needs about 290 votes, the most likely path, partly because more than 100 members who aren't returning may be absent. If it dies, the Big Ten and SEC have discussed conference-led governance. Who ends up writing the rules for college sports in 2027? Read more
Insight of the Week
About 5x
The San Jose Earthquakes were sold to private equity executive Heath Freeman at a reported $625 million enterprise value. Seller John Fisher paid a $20 million expansion fee in 2007, so the headline return looks like 31x. But the price also includes PayPal Park, which Fisher and his partner privately financed, and the Las Vegas Review-Journal reported Fisher led a $100 million investment to build it. Add that in and the return is closer to $120 million, which makes the multiple about 5x. That is my math, and it ignores operating losses, later capital spending and Fisher's 2016 buyout of his partner. The club did not disclose terms, the figure comes from sources, and the deal has not closed.
Here's my read. The price landed only about 4% above Sportico's January 2025 estimate of $600 million, after a sale process that ran about 17 months. And according to the San Francisco Standard, citing Spotrac, the club has not had a top-half payroll in MLS in 10 years. To me, that suggests buyers are paying for a scarce league slot and an owned venue, not the team on the field. The club even leases that stadium to Bay FC, which is income that does not depend on the standings.
When a team underperforms for a decade and still sells at its valuation, what is the buyer actually underwriting? Reply and tell me.
Looking Ahead
- Sports Tech Nation (Munich, December 1-2). A sports innovation summit where startups, investors, brands and sports organizations meet.
- Intercollegiate Athletics Forum (Las Vegas, December 8-9). Sports Business Journal's annual gathering on the business of college sports.
- Super Bowl LXI Sports Media Summit (Los Angeles, February 12). An invitation-only gathering presented by YouTube during Super Bowl week, focused on the future of sports media and the fan experience.
- MIT Sloan Sports Analytics Conference (Boston, February 25-26). Brings together leaders in sports analytics, business and technology.
If you're attending any of these, reply and let me know. I'd love to connect.
Odell